PIE STORE › Easter Pies for pickup 4/4 through 4/5 (48 hours notice required) Image 1 of 1 Easter Pies for pickup 4/4 through 4/5 (48 hours notice required) from $42.00 Our 11" handmade pies are made with wonderful Wisconsin eggs, butter, milk, cream and other excellently sourced ingredients. Serves 8-12 people. Flavor: Select Flavor Key Lime Chocolate Cream Banana Cream Whiskey Walnut Pecan Door County Cherry w/ Streusel Classic Apple w/ Streusel Add To Cart Added! Our 11" handmade pies are made with wonderful Wisconsin eggs, butter, milk, cream and other excellently sourced ingredients. Serves 8-12 people.