For slices of pie to pick-up order through our sister cafe Beard & Belly - HERE PIE STORE PIE STORE Clear PIE | Categories Categories Select a Category PIE Filters Close Filter Clear Filter Thanksgiving Pies (Available from Nov. 20th - 29th. Closed Nov. 26th. 48 hours notice required. ) from $44.00 Select Flavor Apple with Streusel Topping Vegan Apple with Streusel Topping Door County Cherry with Streusel Topping Vegan Door County Cherry with Streusel Topping Pumpkin Whiskey Walnut Pecan Key Lime Chocolate Cream Chocolate Hazelnut Add To Cart Added! Gratuity to the Bakeshop Team! from $5.00 Select TIP $5.00 $10.00 $15.00 $20.00 Add To Cart Added! Classic Fruit Pies (Not available Nov. 20th - 29th. 48 hours notice required) from $44.00 Select Flavor Apple Cherry Blueberry Peach Cherry Apple Peach Blackberry Mixed Berry Add To Cart Added! Classic Cream Pies (Not available Nov. 20th - 29th. 48 hours notice required) from $44.00 Select Flavor Banana Cream Caramel Banana Chai Chocolate Cream Coconut Cream Cookies and Cream Mint Chocolate Add To Cart Added! Specialty Pies (Not available Nov. 20th - 29th. 48 hours notice required) from $46.00 Select Flavor Key Lime Whiskey Walnut Pecan Coconut Key Lime Black Bottom Banana Salted Caramel Lemon Blueberry Chocolate Hazelnut Milwaukee Mud Bourbon Fudge (Pie of the Month) Pumpkin Add To Cart Added! Quiche (48 hours notice needed) $44.00 Bacon, Cheddar & Scallion Carmelized Onion, Mushroom, Spinach, Sun-dried Tomato & Swiss Add To Cart Added! No results found No results match your search. Try removing a few filters.
