PIE STORE › Classic Cream Pies (48 hours notice required) Image 1 of 1 Classic Cream Pies (48 hours notice required) from $44.00 Our 11" handmade cream pies are made with wonderful Wisconsin eggs, butter, milk and cream. Serves 8-12 people…or one very happy person. Flavor: Select Flavor Banana Cream Caramel Banana Chai Chocolate Cream Coconut Cream Coffee Cookies and Cream Mint Chocolate Add To Cart Added! Our 11" handmade cream pies are made with wonderful Wisconsin eggs, butter, milk and cream. Serves 8-12 people…or one very happy person.
Image 1 of 1
Image 1 of 1
Image 1 of 1
Image 1 of 1